Planning matters

Our award winning blog gives a fresh perspective on the latest trends in planning and development.

Green is the new black

Green is the new black

Justine Matchett 25 Apr 2017
Last month in France a law came into force requiring all new commercial buildings to be equipped with either rooftop vegetation (a green roof) or solar panels. France is the first country to enact such a requirement. Whilst the benefits of solar panels are widely appreciated there is, in my experience, less understanding amongst architects and developers in the UK about the benefits of green roofs. The concept of a green roof goes back as far as the Hanging Gardens of Babylon, one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World, believed to have been a series of intensive green roofs built by Nebuchadnezzar II for his wife who was homesick for the plants of Persia. These days, green roofs are generally one of three different types: intensive – parks and gardens including urban agriculture; semi-intensive – garden green roofs; and extensive – natural low maintenance green roofs. The latter are the most common these days in the UK and can take the form of either sedum or biodiverse roofs. In the past green roofs were seen primarily as a way of satisfying planning requirements to provide external amenity space in urban areas. However more recently it has become clear that they offer a wide range of other benefits which, if properly understood, could increase their attractiveness to the development industry. Green roofs help to reduce urban heat islands which result from roads and buildings becoming impermeable and trapping excess heat.  In warm climates, this can result in cities becoming nearly 3 degrees centigrade warmer during the day and up to 12 degrees at night. Green roofs are now known to decrease the heat transfer through the ceiling which improves the energy efficiency of buildings. Recent research by Universidad Politécnica de Madrid[1]   shows that, when vegetation density is high, the incoming heat into the building through the roof is 60% lower than the incoming heat without vegetation. Essentially a green roof with high density vegetation works as a passive cooling system, making it particularly suitable for use in warmer climates. Green roofs impact the process of water cooling in chillers and improve the efficiency of heating, ventilation and air conditioning systems through reduction of temperature around them in the summer. Research into the effect of green roofs in different climates[2] showed that green roofs are able to reduce the cooling energy demand in summertime up to six percent, whilst at the same time having a negligible impact on energy consumption in cold seasons.   In cooler climates, green roofs also act as a wind shield which leads to reduction of heating energy demand. Green roofs can also make a valuable contribution to surface water drainage, having the ability to limit storm water runoff by between 50% and 90%. They can also help reduce air pollution by providing a natural filter for pollution. Green roofs can increase the flora and fauna diversity in urban areas and they decrease the rate of carbon-dioxide emissions by converting carbon dioxide into oxygen via photosynthesis. An important factor to consider when designing any green roof is the dead load capacity (or weight) that the roof exerts onto a building. Whilst retrofitting can be difficult, new buildings can easily be designed to ensure that they can withstand the weight of a green roof, making them a viable option on many sites. Admittedly green roofs have higher capital costs than their traditional counterparts. This is particularly true in the UK, as they are relatively uncommon at present. Capital costs for extensive green roofs are generally between 150-200% more that traditional ‘black’ roofs. Since they are currently not common in the UK, there are few specialist contractors available and this is probably one of the primary causes of the increased capital costs. Maintenance of extensive roofs however is about the same as a traditional roof, only requiring visual inspections every six months. With the increased lifespan of a green roof (approximately double that of a tradition roof) the number of times the roof has to be repaired or replaced is halved - meaning that the introduction of a green roof can actually reduce maintenance requirements and costs. In an ideal scenario, a green roof would be complemented by the addition of photovoltaics to generate electricity.  Research shows that the two uses are complementary, since the cooling effect of the planting increases the efficiency of the photovoltaics. The original draft law put before the French Senate proposed solar and green roofs rather than a choice between the two. This would have removed the choice between technologies and promoted ‘biosolar’ roofs that deliver both biodiversity and renewable energy generation. Unfortunately the Senate concluded that such a requirement would result in “a negative impact on the economic vitality and employment”. Nevertheless, unlike the UK, the tariffs for renewables are still favourable in France and in some parts of the country, there are incentives for green roofs - so biosolar roofs may have a future in France after all. Back in the UK Lichfields is working on a planning application for a residential development in the north east of England which incorporates an extensive sedum green roof across the entire 1,500 square metre roof area, along with 40 square metres of photovoltaic panels. The size of the photovoltaics in this project has been limited not by cost but by the potential generating capacity of the site.  The installation of technologies which are capable of generating more than 12kWp of electrical energy cannot be assumed to be acceptable to the local electricity network operator.  Even though one may not want to export the electricity generated, the operator still has a say. Anything above 12kWp needs the agreement of the network operator; below 12kWp, no agreement is necessary. In preparing the application, a review was undertaken of the local heat map for the area, which details the likelihood of larger scale electrical generating systems being approved. The heat map showed that the installation of a larger scale system in this location is unlikely to be accepted. To limit objections to the application, the client decided to keep the application to panels with a maximum generating capacity of 12kWp. It is clear that there are many reasons why biosolar roofs are not being developed at a faster rate in the UK and there needs to be more encouragement to deliver such schemes. If such schemes are viable in north east England, then there is no doubt that they could be successfully delivered elsewhere in the UK as well.   [1] OLIVIERI, F.; DI PERNA, C.; D'ORAZIO, M.; OLIVIERI, L.; NEILA, J. “Experimental measurements and numerical model for the summer performance assessment of extensive green roofs in a Mediterranean coastal climate”. Energy and Buildings 63: 1-14. DOI: 10.1016/j.enbuild.2013.30.054. AUG 2013 [2] Ahmadi H, Arabi R, Fatahi L. Thermal Behavior of Green Roofs In Different Climates. Special Issue of Curr World Environ 2015;10(Special Issue May 2015)  

CONTINUE READING

EIA Brexit

EIA Brexit

Liz Evans 06 Jul 2016
Okay so I thought it would be close but I did not think it would be that close. And I also did not think that a majority would actually vote to leave the EU… Having slightly recovered from the shock – like most people – I have entered a stage of acceptance and I want to know more about all sorts of things, including how the vote for Brexit might affect NLP’s (‘EIA’) team, whose very existence is defined by an EU Directive. In terms of the requirement or otherwise for EIA, nothing changes for the foreseeable future. The EIA Directive still remains in force, as do the current separate EIA Regulations for England, Scotland and Wales. And the requirement for the ‘new’ Directive 2014/52/EU to be transposed into UK law by 16 May 2017 also remains. This is because, even if notice is given soon to leave the EU under Article 50 of the Treaty on the European Union, the UK has 2 years to complete the process (unless an extension is agreed), with EU legislation remaining in place until departure.The Government is likely to need every single second of those two years, if not longer, given the estimated 80,000 pages of EU agreements that someone needs to decide whether to keep, amend or repeal and the renegotiation or replacement agreements with Member States individually or in groups. During the two years, the primary focus is also likely to be on the process of leaving the EU and governing the UK, as well as stabilising the economy and trade. EIA and environmental protection will remain important but are unlikely to be top of the agenda. So where does that leave EIA?Legal experts fully expect that we will see primary/emergency legislation passed that retains current legislation and case law in the immediate future and intervening period, until possible replacement. The Government may also introduce legislation with a mechanism to deal with issues arising on an ad hoc basis, until we know the full consequences of leaving the EU. If or how this actually plays out is unknown, but legislation along these lines will certainly be needed if there is to be any clarity for EIA – and the many other legal matters currently covered by EU legislation.One benefit of the UK’s EIA Regulations is that they are a standalone set of regulations that can continue to remain in force for qualifying development projects. However there will inevitably be gaps in some policy areas as a result of referential drafting (where the UK has adopted skeleton legislation that relies on EU legislation to fill the gaps) and technical standards and targets currently set at the EU level (such as the UK’s international climate targets, which are currently negotiated as part of the EU block). There has also been a vacuum in UK environmental policy for some years because EU legislation has been so active in this area and the UK Government has left it to EU legislation to do the job.So what can be done in the meantime? The Government is certainly going to need a bit of help from people with the right knowledge and expertise. In a period of austerity, where jobs have at worst been cut and at best not been replaced, the necessary people may not be in place to ensure that the best arrangements are established going forward. It is therefore important that dialogue channels are open with policy-makers to ensure that important legislation is not lost and any new or amended legislation is forward-thinking and robust.With regards to the 30-40 years of case law on the interpretation of EU Directives which influences our work on an almost daily basis, legal experts suggest that a cut-off date is set to clarify when matters should be referred to which court and to define the applicability of existing case law. Even after the cut-off date, European Court cases will still be relevant and should still be binding – although a litigious movement may emerge that seeks to challenge decisions made by a different decision-maker, under different law.Ultimately it seems that in a time of uncertainty, there is actually quite a bit of certainty about EIA. It is not going anywhere soon and NLP’s EIA work will continue unaffected; the Company is ready and poised too, to input into the review process as and when required.  

CONTINUE READING